Skip to content
All posts

Why Reddit and Certain Auto Transport Platforms Aren’t Reliable — Lessons from Real Experiences

By  Bigfella Auto Express  ·  2 minute read

When it comes to shipping a vehicle, many people turn to Reddit or auto transport forums for advice. Subreddits like r/AutoTransport or posts on various platforms can seem helpful, but as someone who runs a licensed and insured auto transport company, I can tell you that relying on these sources can be risky.

At Bigfella Auto Express, we’ve encountered multiple situations that highlight just how unreliable crowdsourced platforms and some brokers’ reviews can be. From fraudulent attempts to skewed feedback, the online auto transport space can be misleading if you don’t know what to look for.

1. Reddit and Online Communities: Conversations, Not Truth

Reddit is a great place to share experiences, but it’s not a reliable source for professional guidance. Anyone can post advice, and upvotes do not guarantee accuracy. One post might describe a cheap rate or a “great carrier,” but it may not reflect reality.

Auto transport involves precise details—insurance coverage, route demand, seasonal factors, and carrier qualifications. A Reddit comment simply can’t provide regulated, verifiable information.

We’ve noticed that some “advice” is repeated across forums, sometimes by users who have no real experience, yet it spreads as fact. This creates confusion and can lead to costly mistakes.

2. Fraudulent Activity We’ve Personally Encountered

We’ve had firsthand experience with some of the more serious risks in the industry. For example:

  • Fraudulent payment attempts: Recently, a customer attempted to submit a $1,040 fraudulent payment. After catching the attempt, the individual spread false information about our business to discredit us. This kind of situation is more common than people realize, and platforms like Reddit offer no protection against these types of schemes.

  • Fake reviews from brokers posing as customers: On multiple occasions, brokers have pretended to be clients to leave glowing reviews for themselves or negative reviews for competitors. These false accounts mislead genuine customers and artificially inflate certain brokers’ reputations.

  • Platform manipulation: There are numerous reports of auto transport brokers leaving reviews for themselves under multiple accounts. Positive reviews are heavily skewed toward certain brokers, while others, including honest businesses, get fewer genuine reviews or are unfairly criticized.

These experiences underscore why relying solely on Reddit or unverified online platforms can put your shipment—and your trust—at risk.

3. Oversimplified Advice Can Lead to Mistakes

You’ll often see posts online like:

  • “Never use a broker.”

  • “All brokers are scammers.”

  • “You should only pay X for this route.”

These statements ignore dozens of real-world factors like driver availability, fuel costs, seasonal spikes, and route restrictions.

At Bigfella Auto Express, we use real-time data, vetted carriers, and FMCSA-compliant practices to provide accurate quotes and safe shipping. Our approach ensures customers aren’t misled by oversimplified advice or misleading online posts.

4. The Proper Way to Research Auto Transport

To protect yourself, here’s how to properly research a shipment:

  1. Verify licensing: Check a broker or carrier’s MC and DOT numbers through the FMCSA.

  2. Check real reviews: Look for verified Google reviews or testimonials with photos. Be cautious if all reviews seem skewed toward a single platform.

  3. Compare quotes: Don’t assume the cheapest option is the best. Consider insurance, service quality, and timing.

  4. Ask questions: A trustworthy broker or carrier will answer questions about insurance coverage, routes, and fees.

  5. Watch for red flags: Multiple anonymous accounts praising the same broker, threats from other parties, or suspicious payment requests are warning signs.

Bigfella Auto Express takes all of this seriously. Every carrier we work with is fully vetted, insured, and accountable. Our quotes are transparent, and we provide real-time updates from pickup to delivery.

5. Conclusion: Trust Experience, Not Anonymous Opinions

Crowdsourced platforms, Reddit posts, and unverified reviews can provide some insight, but they can’t replace professional guidance. At Bigfella Auto Express, we combine industry experience, verified carriers, and transparent, accountable service to protect your vehicle and your peace of mind.

If you’re planning to ship a car, don’t rely on forum advice or skewed platform reviews. Use licensed professionals who track industry trends, verify carriers, and handle fraud prevention proactively. Bigfella Auto Express is here to provide the reliable, transparent service Reddit can’t offer.